Teacher Notes

Plant Wars

Allelopathy Study Kit

Materials Included In Kit

Lettuce seeds, ~ 600
Petri dishes, 45
Radish seeds, ~ 600

Additional Materials Required

Water, tap
Labels or marker
Paper towels
Scissors

Safety Precautions

Plant materials (or any other materials) used during laboratory investigations should never be consumed. Seeds are often treated with mold inhibitors and other chemicals. Remind students to wash hands thoroughly with soap and water before leaving the laboratory.

Disposal

Seedlings may be disposed of in the trash according to Flinn Suggested Disposal Method #26a.

Teacher Tips

  • Enough materials are provided in this kit for 30 students working in pairs or for 15 groups of students. The initial laboratory activity can be set up in 20–30 minutes. Observations and watering will require about 5 minutes a day until the final observations are recorded.

  • Both lettuce and radish seeds sprout easily and quickly if kept warm and moist. Results from this lab are highly predicable. The seeds will sprout in several days and the full effect will be evident in 4–5 days.
  • This topic tends to be of high interest to students and is also a good opportunity for students to design and conduct their own experiments as an extension to this laboratory. Experiments to show allelopathy usually require simple techniques and simple equipment. Encourage students to design controlled experiments. Then provide the time and equipment for students to conduct the experiments. When all experiments are completed, hold an allelopathy seminar to share results.

    The following list of common plants are known to have alleleopathic “toxins.” This list might be a good starting point for student experimental designs.

    Bleeding Heart 
    Calla Lily 
    Chrysanthemum 
    Crocus
    Daffodil 
    Hyacinth 
    Iris 
    Lily of the Valley 
    Magnolia 
    Monkshood 
    Morning Glory 
    Oleander 
    Pines
    Poppies
    Ragweed
    Rhododendron
    Rhubarb
    Sage 
    Sweat Pea
    Tulip
    Walnuts
    Willow
    Wisteria 
    Yew 

    What effects do extracts from these plant have on the growth of other plants? How might a landscape architect benefit from this knowledge? How about a florist? What happens if the lettuce seeds are given a head start?—will the radishes still inhibit the growth later?

Correlation to Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS)

Science & Engineering Practices

Constructing explanations and designing solutions
Engaging in argument from evidence

Disciplinary Core Ideas

MS-LS1.B: Growth and Development of Organisms
HS-LS1.B: Growth and Development of Organisms

Crosscutting Concepts

Cause and effect

Performance Expectations

MS-LS1-4. Use argument based on empirical evidence and scientific reasoning to support an explanation for how characteristic animal behaviors and specialized plant structures affect the probability of successful reproduction of animals and plants respectively
MS-LS1-5. Construct a scientific explanation based on evidence for how environmental and genetic factors influence the growth of organisms.

Sample Data

{10329_Data_Figure_1}

Answers to Questions

  1. Do radish and lettuce have an allelopathic relationship?

    It would appear from the results that radish seeds somehow affect the germination/sprouting of lettuce seeds.

  2. Hypothesize what the mechanism of allelopathy might be between radish and lettuce?

    Perhaps a chemical found or produced by the radish sprouts inhibits the sprouting of the lettuce seeds.

  3. Design an experiment that might demonstrate the mechanism working between radish and lettuce seeds.

    Extract chemicals from radish seeds and test them on lettuce seeds. Observe effects on the sprouting of the lettuce seeds.

Student Pages

Plant Wars

Introduction

Have you ever noticed that plants do not seem to grow under pine trees? What is the reason for this? Can plants defend their own space and prevent others from growing in their area?

Concepts

  • Allelopathy

  • Toxicity

Background

Allelopathy is a process by which certain plants release chemicals which inhibit the growth of other plants. One of the best known examples is the black walnut, Juglans nigra, which contains a chemical called juglone, mostly in its roots, which is toxic to many species of plants. Tomatoes and many other vegetables suffer “walnut wilt” and die as soon as their roots come in contact with the roots of a walnut tree. Walnut chemicals cause allergic reactions in some people and may be toxic to some animals.

The exact mechanisms of how allelopathy works varies and is not well understood. There are most likely many cases of allelopathic effects of one plant upon another that have not yet been identified. In nature, by inhibiting potential competitors, allelopathic plants might enjoy an advantage in the struggle for growing space, soil nutrients, water and sunlight.

Materials

Water, tap
Labels or markers
Lettuce seeds, 40
Paper towels
Petri dishes, 3
Radish seeds, 40
Scissors

Safety Precautions

Plant materials used during laboratory work should never be consumed. Seeds are often treated with mold inhibitors and other chemicals. Wash hands thoroughly with soap and water after handling seeds and other plant material.

Procedure

  1. Make paper towel disks at least five layers thick to fit inside the bottom of three Petri dishes. To do this, trace the bottom of a Petri dish to draw a circular pattern on the paper towel and cut inside the pattern line to create disks just slightly smaller than the inside of the Petri dish bottom.
  2. Place a five-layer paper towel disk in the bottom of each of the three Petri dishes.
  3. Label the three Petri dishes as follows:

“L” (lettuce)
“R” (radish)
“L/R” (lettuce and radish)

  1. Saturate the paper towel disks with water in all three Petri dishes. Try to use the same volume of water in each Petri dish.
  2. Evenly space approximately 25 lettuce seeds in the bottom of the dish labeled “L.” Evenly space 25 radish seeds in the bottom of the dish labeled “R.” In the dish labeled “L/R” place equal numbers of lettuce and radish seeds (12–13 seeds each), interspersing them throughout the dish.
  3. Replace the covers on the dishes and place the Petri dishes in a warm spot. A growth chamber, plant stand, greenhouse or other controlled environment is ideal. Otherwise, find a window sill or other location that will not get much below room temperature.
  4. Examine the dishes daily. Add water to each dish as necessary to keep the bottom saturated with water. Notice which seeds have germinated and which seeds have not.
  5. When the majority of seeds in both the “R” and “L” dishes have germinated and when the sprouts are nearly as tall as the Petri dish, record observations on the Allelopathy Worksheet. Draw a sketch of the seedlings and their numbers in the circles provided on the worksheet. Complete the Post-Lab Questions on the worksheet.
  6. Dispose of the seedlings as directed by your instructor.

Student Worksheet PDF

10329_Student1.pdf

Next Generation Science Standards and NGSS are registered trademarks of Achieve. Neither Achieve nor the lead states and partners that developed the Next Generation Science Standards were involved in the production of this product, and do not endorse it.